Buddy Holly's face on that album cover—those glasses—became synonymous with death, when I was five or six. The bad kind of death: early, unexpected, presumably gorey. As a child, I asked myself How does one die in a plane crash? Fortunately, the screen of my mind always went blank at the moment of impact, and Mr. Holly met his maker with his glasses frames intact—perhaps a bit crooked.
He was my half-brother Jimmy's favorite musician, and the world (that is to say, my mother) knew that Jimmy mourned him—acutely, personally.
That is, perhaps, my first memory of my oldest brother: that he was Buddy Holly's widow.
I stared at the airplane crash face.
He was not meant to live.
I had in common with all children the understanding that what took place in life was canonical, technically flawless.
The proof of this was my father's death, distilled to me in the hushed phraseology of the Lord's Prayer: heart attack, 33 years old, loved by everyone.
It is a bookend of my life.
Its mate, thankfully, has yet to be placed.
* * *
My half-brother Jimmy was 22 when I was 7.
He worked at a hardware store in a little 1950s strip mall that still stands, largely unchanged. The five contiguous shops—covered in what has been called Garden State brick facing—were each set a half-step below the previous one like a line of Cocker Spaniels posed for a photograph.
It often happened that I'd have to go to work with Jimmy—all day—when my mother couldn't score a babysitter. She made peanut butter sandwiches for Jimmy and tunafish sandwiches for me. I spent the entire work day in the break room, sometimes coming out in the afternoon to walk up and down the short aisles looking at ball valves and drawer pulls or watching Jimmy grind keys.
Perhaps it was during this period, or just before, that he had his natty phase. He certainly lost it quickly, yet in those early Kodaks of my mother's—sun-baked, aquarelle—I see him reading on the patio, his legs propped up with such enviable confidence, his form underlined in sharkskin trousers and a white Brooks Brothers shirt with the sleeves rolled practically to his armpits, or an all-black gangster in a white tie posed on the family sofa.
He was a marlin with a crew cut, beached for a quick photo.
I knew him by his cars.
First a vanilla Ford Falcon, then the shirt-blue VW Bug that defined him.
I stood in the padded bucket of empty space behind the rear seat on his dates with Joanie, or pulled pornographic playing cards from his glove compartment and displayed them for my mother like cat's prey.
By the time his red Scout started to appear in the parking lot of our apartment complex, he'd become less my brother and more the father of Jane, with another on the way. His dirty, shoulder-length hair and skin already told the story of the compulsive smoking that was to kill him at 55. Now divorcing, now expecting another baby, the couple staggered toward their forties with a depressing verismo of physical violence and emotional incompatibility that was like a stain on the clean, starched white fabric of what had been their flirty intelligence and collegiate good looks.
For Jimmy's had been the first love story I'd witnessed, the first Christmas present with an engagement ring hidden inside it, my mother's first test drive as a grandmother.
And my first exposure to a male.
* * *
Jimmy was the oldest of three boys my mother had before—apparently abruptly—leaving her husband. The boys lived with their father and his new wife in a modern, split-level house with a sun porch and a two-car garage, a fencing off that was as implicitly social as it was explicitly economic: my mother was a fallen woman.
In each of those sons the failure of that marriage could be conveniently, if heartbreakingly, mapped: Jerry, the youngest, seemed barely to know his mother and stated to the judge his preference for remaining in his father's custody—a piece of ice that was never to melt in their lifetimes. The blonde, pixie-ish middle boy, Bruce Wayne, adored his mother as only the heart of a gay child could, yet the odor of his father's aftershave—and possible, impossible, conditional approval—pushed him into musical achievement and enlistment in the army, only one of which served the individual he was to become. Bruce was to remain divided between the ostensibly functional environment of his father's home—Baptist Church services on Sunday, but still highballs on Saturday night—and the expatriate indulgences of my mother's smaller, more defined world.
Jimmy was her first born, the baby of a 16-year-old girl in rural Maine of exceptional beauty but borrowed clothes. I have the silver identification bracelet, barely six inches in circumference, she gave her lover, 17 months her junior: To Jim with Love, Marion. It was the Second World War, and Jim Campbell was at the Naval Radio Station in Winter Harbor. The snapshots of the two of them, photographed separately and, later, together, make it easy to imagine their lovemaking: he—wirey, pretty, dirty-minded—negotiating the edifice of her languid, peachy, movie-star stature, sexually determined but in a sort of awe that, decades after their divorce, refused to depreciate, to become casual.
For within those sepia prints walks a young woman carrying an accidental, extraordinary gift—a windfall of beauty, unclassifiable, handsome, above all confident. That confidence never entirely deserted her.
So Jimmy was a love child, as I was, but he at the beginning, and me at the end, of this woman's youth.
United by this, we were—quite comically—on one occasion abruptly divided.
* * *
If the dinner table is the truest biographer, then it would be oval-shaped, metal, faux woodgrain, and with padded vinyl chairs that held—on school nights—but two people: my mother and myself.
The sacred text of my father turned out to be false. He'd killed himself at 33 and left my mother without resources or employable skills, and she moved from selling Avon to counter work at Wannamaker's and finally to secretarial stints thanks solely to her good looks.
Apparently from his teens Jimmy was anxious to get out of the Campbell household, and the photos document him hanging around the house my mother occupied before and for a short time after my father's suicide.
Job after job—in the trailer and different apartments my mother cycled through, with only a set of silver-rimmed grocery store china, a gray and cream portable Zenith TV, a cedar wardrobe, a dresser and night stand, and that faux woodgrain dining table—Jimmy followed my mother and me, a sometimes resident.
His worst job was the night shift at Phoenix Steel, arriving back to the apartment in the morning in sooty, grimy clothes just as we were leaving for work and school.
"Don't bring those in here!"
That tone of my mother's, so terrifying to me, translated merely as a suggestion to Jimmy.
He'd sit at the table addressing his resume to different financial organizations:
"My qualifications, thus viewed, would be an asset to your concern."
His mockery was, of course, commensurate with his intelligence—a trait from his skinny father.
The timbre of his voice, in mockery or otherwise, had the inwardly gasping cut off characteristic of some singers. The lack of projection was not a mumble, but, rather, a sort of conceited self-pleasure, spoken always with a half smile. He expected to be heard.
Whether taking the lead in fetching half-gallons of milk from the Acme or moving the heavy naugahyde sofa bed to accommodate my mother's Saturday morning vacuuming, at some point in the work of my pre-adolescent self-definition, Jimmy's presence in the household that all my young life had seemed to be just my mother and me became—suddenly—a threat.
"I'm the daddy in this house!"
I guess it was at dinner that, one night, I must have blurted out my position.
I was to spend the rest of my life attempting such visibility, making such statements—of love, of rage, of fear—that I might not, for those I loved or strangers alike, exist at all.
Even after all these years, it is not difficult for me to imagine the smile—though I cannot remember his words—with which Jimmy would have greeted this important information.
From then, until I was about 14, Jimmy never called me anything but Big Daddy.
* * *
I didn't really know Jimmy.
I didn't know my mother, for that matter.
I was too busy being myself, a child, among them.
Weekdays of my mother hunched over the kitchen sink with a plastic bottle of Nice 'n Easy, a bath towel over her shoulders, seemed agonizingly determined—but cheerful. Uncountable bag lunches, ashtrays parked on the kitchen counter to cool, fumes from Christmas Eve's egg nog and card games on rainy Memorial Day weekends at the Jersey shore—a handful of different cats, different boyfriends—came and went to a soundtrack of Dinah Washington forever singing
Unforgettable, that’s what you are Unforgettable, though near or far […] Please, won't you think that I am Unforgettable, too.
And now those photos—stiff-backed, too shiny for my magnifying glass—play a monotonous melody that refuses to deepen.
Gazing out from a terrarium of solitude, from decades poured out upon the sidewalk like spoiled milk, their faces pause. Cigarettes squashed out, tummies sucked in, those wan smiles bite down hard on tablets of pain or desire that will not read for the camera.
The paintings I have tell a more satisfying story.
A watercolor by one of his daughters shows Jimmy slouched over a newspaper, or perhaps his stock trading documents, cigarette in hand. The paintings were Christmas gifts the year their father died, and when Jane opened hers she gave a single, sudden sob, like a hiccup, then silenced herself.
In one of three paintings Bruce did of my mother, she's still sporting the Angie Dickinson blonde; in another, the cropped auburn of her forties, a nipple showing just at the art board's bottom edge. His massive medieval-themed self-portrait stares down, haughtily, at me when I sit at the piano—still the bitchy queen.
Jerry still lives—besides me, the only one left.
I see the Facebook photos of his face, standing next to a fan of Bruce's (Bruce went on to a brief musical fame, then died from AIDS). I search this photo, too, as I have the old ones, looking for I don't know what.
Perhaps it's just my imagination—my only skill—that sees a wary kindness, stretched like a fitted bedsheet across a childhood that was forced to start over.
Is my mother's face there, in his smile?
He revered his oldest brother—Jimmy.